John Edwards of Denbighshire (Feb. 8, 1683 - Mar. 6, 1757)

-

Look around Edwards genealogy on the internet and you'll see this claim:

John Edwards

b. Feb. 8, 1683 Denbighshire, Wales

d. Mar. 6, 1757 Rockingham County (or Spotsylvania County, etc.), Virginia

Usually this person is said to be married to someone called "Jane Everington (Arrington)."

He is sometimes associated with the Cherry Grove Plantation of King William County, Virginia, which according to Peyton Neale Clark was founded by Ambrose Edwards around 1745. Clark makes no mention of a John Edwards in this generation.

Let me assure you, this John Edwards never existed. He is a confusion of at least two different historical men named John Edwards:

1. Dr. John Edwards (c.1685 - 1743) who owned land in Westmoreland, Spotsylvania and King George Counties in the early 18th century. He is believed to have been married to a Jane Arrington. His estate was probated by Anne Edwards and a possible relative of hers, Richard Tutt, on December 2, 1743 in King George County, Virginia.

2. John Edwards of Haverhill, Massachusetts (c.1683 - Mar. 6, 1757), immigrant from Wales to New Hampshire c.1710. Husband of Lydia Crockett. They married in 1712 in Portsmouth, New Hampshire, and had sons John and Nathaniel. After her death he married Elizabeth Crockett. See this link to view a transcript of John Edward's death. Remember the Julian calendar date difference.

Edwards Heirs "researchers" confused these two men in their genealogical ramblings at some point and they have been mushed together into a single, fictitious man ever since.

Please see The Descendants of Meredith Edwards for an exhaustive study of the Virginia man.

And see A Genealogical Record of the Descendants of John Edwards for the Massachusetts family.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Who was Thomas Nathaniel Edwards?

-
Image
Many Edwards genealogists digging into the colonial period have come across the name "Thomas Nathaniel Edwards." He is usually said to have born in Wales on October 14, 1690 and died in an unknown location in February or November 1781. Some entries call him "Sir" and say he was from a wealthy family that owned an estate called "Edwards Hall" in Wales. He is said to have been a merchant nobleman (or clergyman) who immigrated to the colonies in the mid 18th century with his wife and children and lived everywhere from New York to Georgia. Descendants claimed he was a loyalist during the Revolution and that his son, Robert Edwards, leased out land in June 1778 that was illegitimately sold to Trinity Episcopal Church in New York City, a lease for which the family was owed money. The resulting "Edwards Fortune" case even ended up in court several times and was dismissed every time. Though these claims were largely debunked, the legend of Thomas N...
Read more

A Walk Through Various Errors in the Edwards Genealogies of Westmoreland Co., Virginia

-
Image
Seldom has a single genealogy been so riddled with mistakes and faulty research as the Edwards family of Westmoreland County, Virginia. Compounding the problems of scarce colonial records was an outright fraud in the 19th century that left genealogists and historians copy-pasting bad information for over a century, and some rare, heroic souls trying to fix the mistakes as far back as the 1930s. With this post, I'd like to show where genealogists went wrong, and hopefully illuminate the real origins of this Edwards family. While a number of fake "traditions" swept quite a few Edwards ancestors into this hot mess, it seems the Edwards family of Westmoreland County, Virginia may be the most impacted. These early gentleman planters spread out into Spotsylvania, King George and Stafford Counties by the 1730s. But by the 19th century, genealogists were already confusing them with unrelated families all over the Tidewater. In each case, the erroneous claim can be identified ...
Read more

The Family Bible of Thomas Edwards of Greenville County, South Carolina

-
Image
I found an absolute gold mine on eBay last week. A Mrs. Dan Hugh Williamson who evidently died in 2009 had done extensive work on the genealogy of Thomas Edwards and Mary Ann McClanahan of Greenville County, South Carolina some decades ago and compiled her research into a single, slightly musty volume titled THOMAS EDWARDS: Westmoreland Co., Virginia to Greenville Co., SC and after coming across it incidentally I managed to buy it. Mrs. Williamson has done some stellar genealogical work, and has even included photocopies straight from the Thomas Edwards family bible. I've transcribed all of the names and dates in the bible here: Thomas Edwards b. Jan. 25, 1762 d. Aug. 7, 1832 Mary Ann McClanahan, his wife b. Aug. 16, 1763 d. Nov. 14, 1841 Thomas and Mary Ann his wife were married Aug. 27, 1782. Their children: 1. William Edwards born Apr. 24, 1784 d. Feb. 10, 1804 2. Thomas Edwards Jr. b. May 10, 1786 d. July 4, 1843. "Was shot on the public road." 3. Peter Edwards b. O...
Read more