Edwards Genealogy of Colonial Virginia

Look around Edwards genealogy on the internet and you'll see this claim: John Edwards b. Feb. 8, 1683 Denbighshire, Wales d. Mar. 6, 1757 Rockingham County (or Spotsylvania County, etc.), Virginia Usually this person is said to be married to someone called "Jane Everington (Arrington)." He is sometimes associated with the Cherry Grove Plantation of King William County, Virginia, which according to Peyton Neale Clark was founded by Ambrose Edwards around 1745. Clark makes no mention of a John Edwards in this generation. Let me assure you, this John Edwards never existed. He is a confusion of at least two different historical men named John Edwards: 1. Dr. John Edwards (c.1685 - 1743) who owned land in Westmoreland, Spotsylvania and King George Counties in the early 18th century. He is believed to have been married to a Jane Arrington. His estate was probated by Anne Edwards and a possible relative of hers, Richard Tutt, on December 2, 1743 in King George County, Virginia....

It seems the primary reason even professional genealogists have gotten the Edwards family of Virginia so mixed up over the last century is a 24-page book published in Havre, France by an obscure genealogist named C. W. Chancellor, M.D.  This book is called Leaves from the Chancellor--Fitzgerald--Cooper--Edwards Tree and in 1895 it introduced to the world the hypothesis that William Edwards of Westmoreland (c.1687-c.1746) was the son of William Edwards (d.1722) and Ann Harrison of Surry County, an idea I've already spent considerable space debunking . But the fascinating thing about this obscure little book is that it seems to be the source for almost all of the early flawed research about the Edwards families of Virginia, in particular, the Westmoreland County clan. In addition to being quoted almost verbatim in the Register of the Kentucky State Historical Society, Vol. 17 No. 49 in 1919 by Henry Strother (who cited it as his "manuscript" by a "prominent member of...

I found an absolute gold mine on eBay last week. A Mrs. Dan Hugh Williamson who evidently died in 2009 had done extensive work on the genealogy of Thomas Edwards and Mary Ann McClanahan of Greenville County, South Carolina some decades ago and compiled her research into a single, slightly musty volume titled THOMAS EDWARDS: Westmoreland Co., Virginia to Greenville Co., SC and after coming across it incidentally I managed to buy it. Mrs. Williamson has done some stellar genealogical work, and has even included photocopies straight from the Thomas Edwards family bible. I've transcribed all of the names and dates in the bible here: Thomas Edwards b. Jan. 25, 1762 d. Aug. 7, 1832 Mary Ann McClanahan, his wife b. Aug. 16, 1763 d. Nov. 14, 1841 Thomas and Mary Ann his wife were married Aug. 27, 1782. Their children: 1. William Edwards born Apr. 24, 1784 d. Feb. 10, 1804 2. Thomas Edwards Jr. b. May 10, 1786 d. July 4, 1843. "Was shot on the public road." 3. Peter Edwards b. O...

When i think about people with hobbies like playing baseball, collecting coins, needlework, or even video gaming, I tend to think most people who spend some time on these things tend to be pretty good at it. After all, how long can you be awful at baseball before your teammates kick you out? For some reason, there don't seem to be any barriers for bad genealogists. The vast majority doing "research" online seem to simply be name collectors, content to pull together the research of others without checking their work and adding them to their own trees (bad enough) or publicly editable trees (even worse). Most seem to be extremely passive about their research, which is fine. But there are those who defiantly post old, badly supported theories continuously without doing a scrap of work themselves. I've found when I actually talk to the folks who are doing this, there are a couple of evident cognitive biases at work: Anchoring bias : when genealogists consider the first th...

I finally wrote a book compiling the research I've done on this family since January 2019. You can find uploaded at archive.org. Click here to go directly to it: The Descendants of Meredith Edwards of Westmoreland County, Virginia I've compiled all the evidence, sources, citations and research from quite a few different sources, explained why I think the relationships are what they are. Every single thing I've ever found on this family is here, so its 83 pages long. I think there is some historical imperative in getting this family right, since it did produce some fairly noteworthy early Americans, including Senator John Edwards (1748-1834), one of the first elected U.S. senators from Kentucky; his sons, Haden (1771-1849) and Benjamin (1780-1837) Edwards, whose Fredonian Rebellion (1826) sparked the Texas secession movement; Gen. John Edwards King (1757-1828), a military hero from Kentucky who served during the War of 1812; Ninian Edwards (1775-1833), governor of I...

I see this stuff over and over again in public trees, posted and re-posted by the thousands. If there's anyone pulling their hair out over these things, here's some red flags to look for that will strongly suggest you're looking at weak research: People in the 17th and 18th centuries with middle names . Yes, some people did have them. But most didn't. Bad genealogists seem to love adding middle names to their colonial ancestors, even if no middle name appears in any record for the individual. Evidently, if they find records of people that are confusing or inconsistent--one guy is named William Smith and another guy from someone else's genealogy with the same wife is named Robert Smith--they will simply add the new first name as a middle name: William Robert Smith. VOILA. Problem solved! People in the 17th and 18th centuries with birth and death dates . This mostly pertains to the colonial south, where parish records are few and far between. ...

Having a recent discussion with a professional genealogist, I felt it necessary to make absolutely clear, with careful documentation, that the John, Thomas and William Edwards who appear in Westmoreland, King George and Spotsylvania Counties between 1708 and 1755 are brothers, and the sons of Meredith Edwards (c.1655-1712) of Westmoreland County, Virginia. Given that William Edwards of Westmoreland is the ancestor of several prominent American politicians, including John Edwards (1748-1833), the first elected senator from Kentucky, Haden Edwards (1771-1849), an early Texas revolutionary, and his son, Haden Harrison Edwards (1812-1865), a Texas legislator, there is some historical significance in getting this genealogy right.  A theory that posits that William Edwards of Westmoreland County was the son of William Edwards (c.1680-1722) and Ann Harrison of Surry County has been widely accepted for several decades. This theory evidently originated from the Register of the K...